Justin McLeod built Hinge on the promise of ending swiping. Now he's betting $18 million that AI conversation, not another algorithm, can finally kill the endless scroll.
Overtone, the dating startup McLeod launched after stepping down as Hinge's CEO in December 2025, has raised $18 million from Match Group, FirstMark Capital and Pace Capital, according to TechCrunch. Yes, Match Group. The same company that owns Hinge, Tinder and OkCupid is bankrolling a would-be rival built by the executive who used to run one of its biggest brands.
McLeod isn't shy about what he thinks is broken in the category he helped build. Overtone is not a dating app, he wrote in announcing the round, describing a service with no profiles that reduce people to stats, quotes and photos, no algorithmic feeds trained on split-second impulses, and no juggling likes, matches and chats across a dozen people at once. Overtone talks to you instead. It's voice and audio first, using AI to learn about a person through spoken conversation rather than a stack of photos and a bio written to sound clever. We get to know each person deeply, learning about them in their own voice, hearing their own unique story, McLeod wrote. And we make only the introductions that are worth making, grounded in relationship science and thoughtful reflection. Overtone plans to launch later this year, in select markets only.
That's a real bet, not a marketing line. Dating apps make money keeping people engaged inside the app, not by getting them off it and into a relationship. McLeod is proposing the opposite: fewer matches, delivered with more confidence, aimed at getting users offline fast. It's an implicit critique of the tagline he built Hinge around, designed to be deleted, a rare admission from a dating app that its own product was the obstacle standing between customers and what they actually wanted. That takes nerve.
Why Match Group is backing a rival to its own app
Relationship therapist Esther Perel has joined Overtone's board, alongside Match Group CEO Spencer Rascoff and leadership advisor Diana Chapman. McLeod is taking the chairman title rather than staying on as day-to-day CEO, though he remains the company's public face. That's telling. Match's own announcement described the arrangement as a strategic spinout, language that signals the company would rather hold equity in whatever replaces swipe-based dating than get blindsided by a startup with no legacy platform to protect.
Rascoff has done this dance before. He co-founded Zillow in 2005, ran it for nearly a decade through its IPO, and grew its revenue from $30 million to $1.3 billion before stepping down in 2019, according to Zillow's own regulatory filings. He took the Match Group CEO job in February 2025 specifically to push AI into the company's aging apps, as CNBC reported at the time. Backing McLeod's rival product isn't a contradiction of that mandate. It's the mandate.
Whether it works is another question
Hinge, meanwhile, has moved on. Jackie Jantos now runs the app McLeod spent a decade building, and Match still counts it among its stronger-performing brands even as swipe fatigue drags on the wider category. Overtone is McLeod's answer to a problem he can no longer solve from inside Hinge: an app built to be deleted still has to get people to open it first.
Whether any of this works at scale is the real question. Perel's seat on the board suggests McLeod wants credibility with therapists and relationship coaches, not just engineers. But human matchmaking services - the ones Overtone is explicitly modeling itself on - have always been slow and expensive to run. That's because they depend on real attention to each person. Handing that attention to an AI model is the entire experiment, and nobody outside the company has tested it yet. For now, the pitch is a founder's word, a board full of credibility, and $18 million behind it.
Also read: OpenAI Is Building a Moveable Screen-Free Speaker as Its First Hardware Product • Australia is rushing to approve AI data centers before backlash grows • Grok Build Quietly Uploaded Developers Entire Codebases to xAI Cloud
